Domestic violence is a deeply troubling issue that impacts not only individuals but families and society as a whole. In Turkiye, domestic violence is a recognized ground for divorce under the Turkish Civil Code. Victims of such violence have the right to seek legal protection, including filing for divorce, to escape harmful situations. The key to obtaining a favorable legal outcome lies in proving the abuse and presenting substantial evidence in court.
This article will explore whether domestic violence can serve as a valid ground for divorce in Turkiye, how it can be proven in court, and the legal protections available to victims.
Before beginning the article, we would like to address other important sources from our website on this matter:
What issues or behaviors can be addressed as grounds for a divorce? Please check our “Grounds for Divorce in Turkiye” article.
For methods and process of a divorce, we recommend you to read our article “Divorce in Turkey: Process, Tips and Consequences”
Domestic violence (especially when the victim is a foreigner) and it’s criminal law results are deeply explained in our article “Legal Questions and Answers Frequently Asked By Foreign Women Living In Turkey”
1. Domestic Violence as a Ground for Divorce in Turkish Law
Under the Turkish Civil Code, spouses are expected to treat each other with mutual respect and support. Domestic violence, in any form—whether physical, psychological, emotional, or sexual—constitutes a violation of these marital obligations. As a result, domestic violence is a valid ground for divorce under Article 166 of the Civil Code, which addresses cases of “irretrievable breakdown of the marriage”.
1.1. Irretrievable Breakdown of the Marriage
According to Article 166, if the marriage has become untenable due to domestic violence, the victim can file for divorce based on the irretrievable breakdown of the marriage. This clause covers a broad range of abusive behaviors, including:
Physical violence: Hitting, slapping, or any other form of bodily harm.
Emotional or psychological abuse: Humiliation, verbal threats, or manipulation.
Sexual abuse: Forced sexual relations or coercion.
Economic abuse: Controlling the spouse’s financial resources or restricting access to money.
If the court determines that the marriage has fundamentally broken down due to domestic violence, a divorce will likely be granted. However, the success of the case depends on the victim’s ability to prove the abuse in court.
2. Proving Domestic Violence in Court
One of the most challenging aspects of divorce cases involving domestic violence is proving that the abuse occurred. In Turkiye, the burden of proof lies on the party seeking the divorce. Therefore, victims must present compelling evidence to convince the court of the validity of their claims. The types of evidence that can be submitted to prove domestic violence include:
- Witness testimony
- Medical reports
- Police records
- Psychiatric evaluations
- Communication records (texts, emails, etc.)
2.1. Witness Testimony
Witness testimony is one of the most common forms of evidence in domestic violence cases. Witnesses can include friends, family members, neighbors, or anyone else who has observed the abusive behavior or its effects. The court may call these witnesses to testify about what they have seen or heard.
However, relying solely on witness testimony can be risky, as witnesses may not always be available, or their accounts may not align perfectly. It is often necessary to supplement witness testimony with other forms of evidence to strengthen the case.
2.2. Medical Reports and Documentation
Medical documentation is one of the most powerful forms of evidence in cases of physical domestic violence. If the victim has sustained any physical injuries as a result of the abuse, it is crucial to seek medical attention and obtain reports detailing the injuries. Medical records should include:
- Descriptions of injuries
- Treatment provided
- Medical professional’s testimony on the cause of injuries
Doctors or medical professionals who treated the injuries may also be called to testify in court about the nature and extent of the harm inflicted on the victim. Photographs of injuries can be attached to medical reports to give the court a clearer understanding of the abuse.
2.3. Police Reports
Filing a police report is another critical step in documenting domestic violence. If the victim has contacted law enforcement during or after an incident of abuse, the police report can be submitted as evidence.
Police officers may also testify in court about their involvement in the case. The existence of multiple police reports can serve as a strong indicator of ongoing abuse and help substantiate claims of domestic violence.
2.4. Psychiatric and Psychological Reports
Domestic violence can have severe psychological effects on the victim, including depression, anxiety, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). In such cases, psychiatric and psychological evaluations can be used to demonstrate the emotional harm caused by the abuse. These reports can provide a detailed analysis of the victim’s mental state, offering insight into the long-term effects of the violence.
A psychiatric report from a licensed mental health professional may be submitted to the court to explain the emotional and psychological trauma the victim has suffered. This can help justify claims for non-pecuniary damages in addition to the divorce itself.
2.5. Communication Records
In today’s digital world, communication records such as text messages, emails, or social media posts can serve as valuable evidence in domestic violence cases. Abusive messages, threats, or controlling behaviors documented in written form can be submitted to the court as evidence. It is important to retain any communication that may demonstrate the abusive nature of the relationship.
Additionally, phone records or recordings (if legally obtained) can be presented to substantiate claims of verbal abuse or harassment. Such records can offer undeniable proof of the abuser’s behavior and support the victim’s case for divorce.
3. Compensation for Victims of Domestic Violence
Victims of domestic violence may be entitled to financial compensation as part of the divorce settlement. In addition to seeking a divorce, the victim can request both financial compensation and non-pecuniary damages to account for the physical and emotional harm they have endured.
3.1. Financial Compensation
Financial compensation can cover various economic losses suffered by the victim due to domestic violence, including:
Medical expenses: Treatment for injuries caused by the abuser.
Loss of income: If the abuse forced the victim to leave their job or affected their ability to work.
Relocation costs: Expenses related to moving to a new home to escape the abuser.
3.2. Non-Pecuniary Damages
Non-pecuniary damages are intended to compensate for the emotional and psychological harm caused by domestic violence. This can include trauma, humiliation, and mental suffering endured by the victim. As discussed earlier, psychiatric evaluations can help substantiate claims for non-pecuniary damages by demonstrating the emotional toll the abuse has taken on the victim’s mental health.
4. Conclusion: Seeking Justice and Protection
Domestic violence is a serious issue that impacts countless families in Turkiye. Fortunately, Turkish law offers victims the opportunity to seek justice through divorce and legal protections. Domestic violence is a valid and powerful ground for divorce, and proving the abuse in court can lead to the dissolution of the marriage and protection for the victim.
However, proving domestic violence requires comprehensive evidence, ranging from medical reports and police records to witness testimony and psychiatric evaluations.
Domestic violence is a multifaceted legal issue. It requires the examination of many issues both in terms of marriage and criminal consequences. In this article, it is discussed only as a ground for divorce. In order to examine other aspects, the other articles mentioned in the introduction of this article can be examined.
Disclaimer: The information and opinions on this page are for general information and academic contribution purposes. It may not reflect the views of Otto Law and Mediation. Due to the fact that law is a dynamic field, the information and opinions on the site may be out of date. The articles on the site may not reflect the prevailing doctrine or common judicial practices in that field and may contain the author’s own legal convictions. The information and legal opinions on this site are not legal advice and these contents are not intended to be legal advice. It is recommended to seek professional legal support for specific cases. Otto Law and Mediation or the author of the relevant article are not responsible for the consequences of applying the information and opinions on the site to concrete events. We present it to your information.
